adaptability 40, 52, 618, 627, 642, 702, 708,
adaptation vs., 618,
as a form of critique, 618, 702,
planning vs., 618, 627, 642, 708
American National Standards Institute (ANSI) 457-458
Apache (Free Software project) 52, 322, 334, 620-624, 622-625, 661-689, 676, 691-692, 805,
individual vs. group innovation, 676
Applied Data Research (corporation) 363
Arendt, Hannah 72
Artificial Intelligence Lab (AI Lab), at MIT 529-539
artificial Intelligence Lab (AI Lab), at MIT 608-614
AT&T 350-352, 370-384, 371, 401, 446, 447, 464-471, 477, 556, 561, 566, 569, 591, 636, 688, 711, 885,
Bell Laboratories, 371, 688, 711,
divestiture in, 591,
divestiture in 1984, 447,
version of EMACS, 561, 566, 569,
version of UNIX, 401, 446
attribution 779, 818, 829, 849,
copyright licenses and, 779, 829,
copyright licensing and, 818,
dissavowal of, 849
Authorship 814-843
availability 40, 442, 480, 506, 886,
open systems and, 40, 442, 480, 506,
reorientation of power knowledge and, 886
Bangalore 131-138
Bentham, Jeremy 522-523
Berkeley Systems Distribution (BSD) (version of UNIX) 334, 401-410, 459, 508, 646, 674, 691, 710-711,
FreeBSD, 646, 674, 691
Berkman Center for Internet and Society 762-763
Bitkeeper (Source Code Management software) 693-705
blogosphere, as recursive public 877
Bolt, Beranek, and Newman (BBN) 404
Bone, Jeff 152-178
Brin, David 157
Brooks, Frederick 364
Bruno, Giordano 492
Burris, C. Sidney 735
Calvinism 286
Chari, Bharath 136
COBOL (programming language) 360
Coleman, Gabriella 517
collaboration 442, 460, 680, 830, 884,
competition vs., 442, 460, 884,
different meanings of, 680,
forking vs., 830
Connexions project 23, 29, 41, 58-59, 62, 722-729, 731, 735, 737, 738, 740, 741, 744, 748, 759, 769, 779, 798, 798, 799, 801, 808, 810, 814, 816,
as Free Software project, 748,
as “factory of knowledge”, 738,
connection to Creative Commons, 759, 769,
history and genesis of, 731,
line between content and software, 808,
meaning of publication, 798,
model of learning, 744,
model of learning in, 737,
modules in, 737,
Open CourseWare, 741, 769,
relationship to education, 740,
relationship to hypertext, 779,
roles in, 810, 814, 816,
stages of producing a document in, 799, 801,
textbooks and, 735, 798
content 750-755
CONTU report 594
coordination (component of Free Software) 52, 315-321, 616-619, 618, 626-635, 636, 648, 662, 666-716, 679, 697, 710, 728, 743, 748, 756, 813, 824,
individual virtuosity vs. hierarchical planning, 618, 648, 662, 679, 710,
modulations of, 697, 743, 748, 756, 813, 824,
of Linux vs. Minix, 636
copyleft licenses (component of Free Software) 147, 744, 748, 825,
derivative uses and, 825,
modulations of, 744, 748, 825
Copyleft licenses (component of Free Software) 310-314, 407, 513, 514-624, 524, 751, 762, 779, 830, 836, 848, 849, 887,
as hack of copyright law, 524,
commercial use and, 779,
Creative Commons version, 848,
derivative uses and, 779, 836, 849,
disavowal clause in, 849,
forking and, 830,
modulations of, 751, 762
Copyright 229-231, 524-525, 525, 539, 545, 586,
changes in 1976, 525, 539, 586,
changes in 1980, 539, 586,
infringement and software, 545,
legal definition of software and, 545,
requirement to register, 586,
rights granted by, 525,
software and copyrightability, 545
copyright 28-29, 391, 604, 765, 807, 815,
changes in 1976, 391,
requirement to register, 765,
specificity of media and, 807,
transfer of, 604,
works for hire, 815
Copyright infringement 558, 561, 568, 569, 582,
EMACS controversy and, 558, 569,
infringement on own invention, 582,
legal threats and, 568,
permissions and, 561
Crain, Patricia 228-229
Creative Commons 23, 29, 41, 58-59, 62, 729-730, 759-785, 762, 765, 769, 778, 818-820, 848,
activism of, 765,
connection to Connexions, 759, 769,
marketing of, 778,
origin and history of, 762,
writing of licenses, 848
culture 20, 115, 134, 723, 844, 856, 860,
as experimental system, 20,
Creative Commons version of, 856,
law vs., 860,
punting to, 844
Defense, Department of 496-507
Delanda, Manuel 520
differentiation of software 352, 401, 412-413, 453-454, 677,
in Apache, 677,
see also forking and sharing source code, 677
Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) 298
Disney, Walt 767
distance learning 740-742
distributed phenomena, ethnography of 65-71
dotcom era 332-336
Dyson, Esther 165
Eldred, Eric 761-764
EMACS (text editor) 211, 519-624, 527, 532, 541, 544, 558, 629, 645, 701, 754, 887,
controversy about, 541, 701, 887,
ersatz versions, 532, 541, 544,
legal status of, 558,
modularity and extensibility of, 527,
number of users, 645
End User License Agreements (EULAs) 517
Evil 435
experimentation 522, 606, 620, 623-624, 714-716, 718, 726-727, 783-784, 832-833,
administrative reform as, 522,
see also modulations, 726
Extropians 264
Feyerabend, Paul 259-260
File Transfer Protocol (ftp) 639
finality 41-43, 789-846, 803, 810,
certainty and stability vs., 789,
fixity vs., 810,
in Wikipedia and Connexions, 803
Free Software 19-22, 20, 25, 45, 48, 55, 291-346, 292, 297, 338, 377, 617, 696, 720, 727, 794,
anthropology and, 720,
as experimental system, 20, 45, 292,
components of, 727,
modulations of, 55, 794,
nonfree tools and, 696,
open source vs., 20, 48, 297, 338, 617,
passim, 377,
relation to Internet, 25
Free Software Foundation 103, 297-298, 324, 328, 604-612, 614, 629, 644-645, 834-835,
cult status of, 629,
Linux and Apache vs., 614
Freeware summit 323-328
Fun, and development of Linux 697
futurology 262-282
geeks 27, 63, 77-83, 101-109, 106, 193, 240, 281, 288-289, 299-302, 341, 345, 501, 512, 609, 716, 772, 812,
as moderns, 193, 240, 281, 716,
hackers vs., 106,
self-representation, 63, 341
Geertz, Clifford 122-125
Gender 135
General Public License (GPL) 310-313, 514-624, 610, 629, 698, 754,
development of, 610,
passim, 698, 754
Gilmore, John 164-165
GNU Hurd (kernel) 629
Goody, Jack 795
Grassmuck, Volker 113
Grune, Dick 690
Gulhati, Ashish 174
Harthill, Rob 671-683
Hayden, Robert 107-109
Holmes, Oliver Wendell 847
Hopper, Grace 355
Housman, A. E. 821
Huxley, Julian 265
ideology 119-125
implementation of software 349
Informatics (corporation) 363
Infrastructure 184-188
institutional economics 780-782
intellectual property 193, 231, 233, 298, 305, 310, 328-329, 388-391, 407-409, 418, 436-442, 514-624, 567, 592, 595-615, 849, 884-887,
strategy and, 567, 592, 849
International Telecommunications Union (ITU) 489-495
Internet 25-37, 36, 67-68, 78-83, 101, 115, 131, 139, 150, 152, 162-171, 164, 172-181, 489, 627, 882,
early development, 489, 627,
folklore and, 164,
geeks and, 101,
idea of order and, 115,
India and, 131,
public spheres and, 139,
relation to Free Software, 25, 627,
singularity of, 36, 150, 152, 882
Johns, Adrian 795-798
Katz, Lou 379-382
Keynes, John Maynard 485
Kittler, Friedrich 795
Labalme, Fen 564-572
lag, technological 256-258
LaTeX (typesetting language) 801
Latour, Bruno 796
legitimacy, circulation of knowledge and 878-884
Lessig, Lawrence 168-170, 761-785, 767, 780, 861,
law and economics and, 780, 861,
style of presentations, 767
liberalism, classical 157
licensing, of UNIX 371-377
Licklider, J. C. R. 403
Linux (Free Software project) 52, 209, 322, 335, 396, 511, 608, 619-627, 630, 649, 651, 684, 691, 693, 736, 805,
origins in Minix, 396, 630,
planning vs. adaptability in, 651,
process of decision making, 649,
Source Code Management tools and, 684,
VGER tree and, 693
Lions, John 386-396
Locke, John 157
Luther, Martin 196-211
mainframes 422-426
Malmud, Carl 491-492
Mannheim, Karl 122-123
McGill, Scott 821
McKenna, Regis 439-440
McLuhan, Marshall 803
McVoy, Larry 694-705
meaning, regulation through law 861
MedCommons 100-102
mergers 462-464
Metcalfe's Law 157
Mickey Mouse 767
microcomputers 426-428
Microsoft 213, 221, 225, 229, 301, 309, 387, 409, 461, 476, 547, 709,
as Catholic Church, 213, 225,
Internet Explorer, 221, 225, 229, 301,
Windows operating system, 387, 409, 476,
Xenix (version of UNIX), 547
Mikro e.V. 112-113
Miller, Dave 693
Minix (operating systems) 630-649
modifiability 38-44, 40-44, 41, 58-59, 441-442, 442, 480-485, 480-484, 508, 534, 592, 637-639, 652, 682, 710-713, 751-755, 773-779, 789, 824-827, 837, 887-891,
EMACS and, 534,
implications for finality, 41, 789,
modularity in software, 652, 682,
relation of different disciplines to, 837
modulation 55, 622, 721, 726, 743, 747, 773, 783, 871,
of Free Software, 55, 622, 721, 783, 871,
practices of, 726, 743, 747, 773
Monopoly 435
Moore's Law 157
moral and technical order 79-82, 129-130, 148-150, 164, 173-174, 184, 188, 190, 194, 235, 273, 331, 342, 348, 384, 408-413, 417-420, 435-436, 452, 482, 511, 534-541, 631, 705, 730, 764, 771-772, 838, 865, 871, 884-889
Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) 160
movement (component of Free Software) 48, 292-295, 322-346, 339, 624, 728-730, 833, 876,
function of, 339,
modulations of, 833, 876
Mozilla Public License (MPL) 311-313
Multi-User Dungeons (MUDS) 628
Nesson, Charlie 775
Net neutrality 36
net.emacs (mailing list) 546-584
Netscape Navigator 319-320
Netscape Public License (NPL) 311
new httpd (mailing list) 665-689
norms 59, 168, 786-798, 790, 813, 825, 827, 835, 839-843, 841-845, 842, 843, 851, 858, 859,
academic, 813, 827, 851,
channeling by legal means, 843, 859,
coordination and, 825,
cultural, 835, 842, 858,
evolution and, 841,
existence of, 59, 790, 839,
practices and technology vs., 835
Novell 477
Ong, Walter 795
Open access 21-23
Open content licenses 755
Open Software Foundation (OSF) 452
Open Source 20, 48, 297, 324, 335, 478, 617, 736,
Free Software vs., 20, 48, 297, 335, 617,
inspiration for Connexions, 736,
“Open Source Definition”, 324
Open Source Initiative 325
Open Sources 334
Open Systems 47, 50, 112, 308-310, 414-513, 434, 447, 481, 519, 540, 612, 884-887,
intellectual property and, 434,
networks and, 481,
operating systems and, 447
Open Systems Interconnection (OSI) 353, 400, 419, 482,
as reference model, 419, 482,
TCP/IP, 353, 400
openness 47-50
Openness (component of Free Software) 419, 432, 476,
proprietary vs., 432, 476,
standardization and, 419
openness (component of Free Software) 412, 414-442, 418, 429, 432, 434, 466, 471, 476-486, 749-751, 751, 825,
closure vs., 434,
definition of, 432,
goals of, 429,
intellectual property and, 418,
modulations of, 749, 825,
proprietary vs., 466, 751,
standardization and, 471,
sustainability vs., 751
operating systems, history of 350-390
O’Reilly, Tim 323
packet-switching 496-497
Pascal (programming language) 400-402
patents on software 586-587
pedagogy 348, 412, 480, 504, 630, 643, 729,
Minix and, 643,
network protocols and, 504,
operating systems and, 348, 412, 480, 630
permission 817-826
practices 41-44, 292, 338-342, 341, 518, 520, 586, 617, 726, 743, 748, 835, 872-874,
five components of Free Software, 292, 520, 617, 726, 743, 748, 872,
norms vs., 835,
opposed to legal changes, 586,
stories as, 341,
“archival hubris”, 341
pragmatism 259
Prentice Hall 639-640
Progress 190-193
protocols 164, 177, 353, 400, 419, 482,
distinguished from standards and implementation, 353, 400,
Open Systems Interconnection (OSI), 419, 482,
TCP/IP, 164, 177, 419, 482
public 23-29, 30-33, 115-130, 142, 144, 148, 181-188, 233, 835, 872-877,
autotelic and independent, 144, 148, 835,
see also recursive public, 872,
self-grounding of, 142
public domain 308, 351, 547, 765-769, 782, 818, 821,
Creative Commons licenses and, 818,
environmentalism and, 782,
literary texts in, 821,
meaning in EMACS controversy, 547
public sphere 25, 34, 38, 70, 115, 620, 879,
recursive public vs., 34, 38, 879,
theories of, 25, 70, 115, 620
QED (text editor) 529
Raelians 264
Rand, Ayn 157
Raymond, Eric Steven 63-64, 297, 323, 325, 327-330, 334-335, 334-335, 338, 341, 344, 448, 626, 708, 720-724
recursion, definition of 84-89
recursive public 23, 32, 35, 77-89, 82, 88, 149, 154, 168, 174, 233, 312, 342, 351, 374, 393-399, 506-509, 520, 538, 619-620, 660, 685, 702, 716, 727-730, 729, 787-789, 812, 835, 865,
definition of, 23, 32,
examples of, 154, 729,
layers of, 35, 82, 88, 149, 154, 168, 174, 685, 702,
precursors of, 351, 374
Red Hat (corporation) 332
Redd, Kross 777
redistribution of software 600-604
Reformation vs. revolution 215
religion 248
Religion 135-136
reorientation of power and knowledge 20-21, 30-44, 182, 346, 441, 501, 520, 716, 782, 788-790, 795, 806-810, 872-891
reverse engineering 701
Richards, Paul 691
Ricoeur, Paul 124-125
Roles, in Connexions 814-843
Rumor on Usenet 664
Sahlins, Marshall 849-851
sampling, musical 861-864
Second Life, as recursive public 877
Shannon, Claude 111
sharing source code (component of Free Software) 48, 348-398, 355, 378, 379, 387, 398-413, 518, 743, 747, 765, 824,
before Software, 355,
legal aspects, 379,
modulations of, 743, 747, 765, 824,
pedagogical aspects, 378, 387,
technical aspects, 379
social imaginary 44, 70-72, 115-130, 118, 124, 142-146, 164-174, 191, 342, 430, 482, 518, 764, 772-773, 880,
ideology vs., 118, 124
social movement, theories of 339
Software 500, 595,
implementation of, 500,
legal definition of source code and, 595,
registration of copyright, 595
software development 243-246, 316-318, 584, 661, 666, 691, 713,
Apache project, 666,
as spectrum, 713,
creating vs. maintaining, 584,
patch and vote method, 661, 691
Software manuals 754
Source code 442-444
source code 355, 359, 361-368, 587-588, 595,
batch processing, 359,
legal definition and, 595,
translation of, 355
Source Code Management tools (SCMs) 617, 623, 684-705, 685, 686, 687, 691, 693,
as tool for distribution, 687,
definition of, 685,
right to “commit” change, 691,
see also Bitkeeper, 693,
see also Concurrent Versioning System (cvs), 686
Stallman, Richard 211, 297-298, 313, 324, 327-330, 332-334, 338, 341, 344, 514-624, 626, 697, 754, 887
Stallman,Richard 645
standards 95, 112, 173, 222, 229, 233, 244, 309, 359, 415-417, 427, 437, 438-442, 445, 452, 458, 473, 485, 500, 508, 883-884,
as form of competition, 427, 437, 445, 458,
implementation, 458, 500,
interface definition as, 452,
Internet, 95, 112, 173, 222, 229, 233,
ownership of, 309, 473,
programming languages, 359,
validation of, 485, 500, 508
Sundaram, Ram 136
System V Interface Definition (SVID) 458
TCP/IP (Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol) 164, 177, 353, 400, 419, 482-509, 497,
goals of, 497,
included in BSD, 400
technology 27, 32, 34, 39, 82, 251, 282, 780,
as argument, 27, 34, 39, 82, 282, 780,
meanings of, 251,
politics of, 32
Teilhard de Chardin, Pierre 265
telecommunications industry 489-494
Terbush, Randy 678
TeX 54
textbooks 394, 639, 722, 750, 834,
model in Connexions, 750, 834,
on operating systems and networks, 394, 639
Thau, Robert 677-683
time 241, 256, 262, 267, 281,
initial conditions and, 281,
singularity and, 267,
technical progress and, 241, 256, 262
Torek, Chris 601
Torvalds, Linus 209-210, 326, 332, 338, 608, 623-626, 626, 693,
autobiography of, 626,
in bitkeeper controversy, 693
Trade secret law 586-592
translation of source code 355-360
Traweek, Sharon 860
Trigdell, Andrew 701
Turing, Alan 355-357
uncertainty, in the law 586-606
Unisys 462-464
UNIX operating system 202, 350-353, 353, 367, 387, 394, 401, 443, 448, 449, 626, 710, 805, 885,
allegiance to versions of, 448, 805, 885,
as commercial product, 394,
as part of speech, 449,
development of, 710,
history of, 367, 443,
Open Systems and, 443,
relationship to Arpanet, 353, 401,
standardization and, 443,
Windows operating system vs., 387
Unix to Unix copy protocol (uucp) 488
Usable pasts 492
Usenix (user group) 377
User groups 664
users, status in Connexions 815
Wall, Larry 332
Weber, Max 66
White Stripes 777-778
Wiley, Davis 755
World Wide Web consortium (w3c) 309
X Windows 480
Xerox PARC 488
Copyright: 2008 Duke University Press
Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper ∞
Designed by C. H. Westmoreland
Typeset in Charis (an Open Source font) by Achorn International
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication data and republication acknowledgments appear on the last printed pages of this book.
License: Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-Share Alike License, available at https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/ or by mail from Creative Commons, 559 Nathan Abbott Way, Stanford, Calif. 94305, U.S.A. "NonCommercial" as defined in this license specifically excludes any sale of this work or any portion thereof for money, even if sale does not result in a profit by the seller or if the sale is by a 501(c)(3) nonprofit or NGO.
Duke University Press gratefully acknowledges the support of HASTAC (Humanities, Arts, Science, and Technology Advanced Collaboratory), which provided funds to help support the electronic interface of this book.
Two Bits is accessible on the Web at twobits.net.
≅ SiSU Spine ፨ (object numbering & object search)
(web 1993, object numbering 1997, object search 2002 ...) 2024